When a patient consults a healthcare professional, they can choose between a traditional medical consultation and a homeopathic consultation. These two approaches differ in several respects, particularly in the diagnostic approach, the treatment method and the therapeutic objective.
So, what are the specific features of each type of consultation?
Holistic approach: two ways of understanding the disease
Traditional medical consultation: a targeted and rapid approach
- Average duration: 15 to 30 minutes
- Main objective: rapidly identify the cause of a specific symptom and propose appropriate treatment
- The general practitioner follows validated medical protocols and focuses on the organ or pathology concerned
Example: A patient comes to consult for frequent migraines. The doctor examines the family history, risk factors, possibly prescribes a brain scan or a blood test, then recommends symptomatic treatment (painkillers, anti-inflammatories).
Homeopathic consultation: an individualised and comprehensive approach
- Average duration: 45 minutes to 1 hour
- The aim is to understand the patient as a whole before proposing a personalised homeopathic remedy
- In addition to the classic medical examination, which allows him to make a diagnosis and possibly prescribe the recommended paraclinical examinations, the practitioner explores the patient’s emotions, lifestyle, physiological and psychological reactions.
Example: For the same migraine, the homeopath seeks to identify the triggering circumstances, the emotional impact, the associated symptoms (sweating, nausea, photophobia), the modalities of improvement or aggravation (rest, cold, noise, etc.). Based on this analysis, a specific remedy (for example, Belladonna, Gelsemium or Nux Vomica) will be chosen.
Key difference: Conventional medicine looks for a biological cause and proposes a standardised treatment, whereas homeopathy will also take into account the overall profile of the patient to determine a personalised remedy.
Diagnosis and treatment: two complementary approaches
Conventional medicine: a diagnosis based on objective examinations
- The doctor uses clinical, biological and medical imaging tools to identify the disease.
- Treatments are mainly medicinal (antibiotics, anti-inflammatories, antidepressants, etc.) or surgical.
- Conventional medicine is based on validated scientific studies and a known risk/benefit ratio.
Example : For a bacterial infection, a doctor prescribes antibiotics after a blood test or sample.
Homeopathy: a selection of remedies based on the principle of similarity
- The homeopath does not rely solely on the pathology (which they will still have identified in order to propose a conventional treatment if they consider the pathology to be serious and/or urgent) , but on all physical, emotional and behavioural symptoms.
- Treatment is based on the law of similars: a remedy that causes symptoms in a healthy person can cure them in a sick person.
- Homeopathic medicines are diluted and dynamised, with no noticeable side effects.
Example: for the flu, a doctor will prescribe paracetamol and rest, while a homeopath may suggest Oscillococcinum, Eupatorium Perfoliatum or Gelsemium, depending on the individual symptoms.
Key difference: Conventional medicine treats a specific medical cause with a standard treatment, whereas homeopathy seeks the remedy best suited to the patient’s constitution.
Therapeutic objective: suppression of symptoms or stimulation of self-healing?
Classical medicine: treating symptoms and the disease
- The main objective is to eliminate or reduce symptoms, while treating the underlying cause.
- Treatments may have known side effects, but their effectiveness is statistically measurable.
- Prescriptions are based on a benefit/risk ratio studied in clinical trials.
Example: a person suffering from seasonal allergies will be prescribed antihistamines to reduce sneezing and itching.
Homeopathy: stimulating the body’s self-healing capacity
- Homeopathy seeks to rebalance the patient’s terrain rather than simply mask the symptoms.
- It aims to strengthen the immune system and physiological balance to prevent the disease from reappearing.
- Treatment is progressive, sometimes over several months for chronic diseases but can be very rapid for acute diseases.
Example: For a patient suffering from allergies, the homeopath may suggest Poumon Histamine, Allium Cepa or Histaminum to regulate the immune response in the long term.
Key difference: Conventional medicine acts directly on the symptoms for rapid relief, while homeopathy acts in depth to restore a lasting balance.
Homeopathy and conventional medicine: opposition or complementarity?
Although the approaches are different, they are not necessarily incompatible.
When to choose a conventional consultation?
- In the event of a medical emergency : heart attack, stroke, appendicitis, fractures, etc.
- For diseases requiring heavy drug treatment (cancers, severe infections).
When to consult a homeopath?
- For a natural approach with no side effects for mild ailments (colds, migraines).
- As a complement to conventional medicine, to optimise healing and provide support for all illnesses, whether acute, chronic, serious or mild, homeopathy can be a safe and drug-free complement.
Conclusion: one patient, two possible approaches
- Classical medicine is essential in serious situations or those requiring a precise diagnosis.
- Homeopathy can be an excellent complement, taking into account the individuality of the patient and stimulating their own balance.
A homeopathic assistant to support you in acute everyday conditions
Thanks to advances in digital technology, it is now possible to obtain personalised homeopathic advice via ‘Hugo’, a specialised virtual assistant.
Our homeopathic assistant offers you:
- A detailed analysis of your symptoms.
- A recommendation of suitable homeopathic remedies.
- 24/7 assistance for a natural and personalised approach to your health.
Find out more about homeopathy and chat with our virtual assistant now!